How to Choose a Smart Lock
Keyless entry replaces a metal key with codes, phone credentials, or a fingerprint, and the installation type determines how much of your existing hardware stays. Deadbolt compatibility, door thickness, and backset measurements decide whether a given model physically fits. Battery life and the behaviour when power runs out matter more than any convenience feature. Credential management is where these earn their keep for households with cleaners, guests, or family coming and going.
Installation Type and Door Compatibility
Interior-only retrofits keep the existing deadbolt and exterior cylinder, replacing just the thumb turn inside. Your keys keep working and the door looks unchanged from outside, which suits rentals and period doors.
Full replacement locks change both sides and offer keypads, fingerprint readers, and better tamper resistance. Measure door thickness, backset, and the cross-bore diameter, since standard figures vary and a lock that does not match will not install correctly.
Credential Types and Everyday Use
Keypads work for anyone without a smartphone and need no battery in the credential. Look for a keypad that resists wear patterns, since worn digits on frequently used numbers effectively advertise the code.
Fingerprint readers are fast when they work and frustrating in cold or wet conditions. Phone-based unlocking using proximity is convenient but depends on the phone having charge and the connection being reliable, so a physical fallback always matters.
Battery Life and Power Failure Behaviour
Most locks run six to twelve months on alkaline cells, with keypad and motor activity the main drain. Cold weather on an exterior door reduces that considerably, sometimes by half.
Critical detail: what happens when batteries die completely. Locks retaining a physical key cylinder are simplest, while others provide external contacts that accept a battery pack to power the lock temporarily. A lock with neither leaves you outside.
Security, Tamper Resistance, and Certification
Physical security still matters, and grading standards for deadbolts indicate resistance to forced entry. A connected lock with excellent software and a weak bolt is no better than the cheapest mechanical lock.
Consider the digital side too: encrypted communication, protection against replay attacks, and a manufacturer with a history of patching promptly. Check whether the lock can be forced into a factory reset from outside, which would be a serious design flaw.
Access Sharing, Codes, and Logs
Time-limited codes for a cleaner or dog walker, single-use codes for a delivery, and permanent codes for family members cover most real needs. Check how many codes the lock supports, since limits of ten or twenty are common.
Activity logs showing who entered and when are valuable, but check retention periods and whether history requires a subscription. Some manufacturers keep only recent events unless you pay, which undercuts the reason many people want the logging in the first place.
Connectivity, Bridges, and Remote Access
Bluetooth-only locks work when you are nearby and need a bridge for remote locking or code management from elsewhere. Wi-Fi built into the lock avoids the bridge but consumes battery considerably faster.
Mesh protocols such as Zigbee, Z-Wave, and Thread offer a good compromise, giving remote access through an existing hub with modest power draw. Confirm auto-lock and scheduled locking run on the lock itself rather than depending on a cloud connection to fire.
What to Check Before You Buy
- Measure door thickness, backset, and cross-bore before choosing a model.
- Decide between an interior retrofit and full replacement based on the exterior appearance you want.
- Confirm what happens when batteries die completely, and whether a key or external contacts exist.
- Check the deadbolt grading rather than judging only on connected features.
- Count how many access codes the lock supports against your household’s needs.
- Verify log retention and whether history requires an ongoing subscription.
- Confirm auto-lock and schedules run on the lock rather than in the cloud.
How to Choose a Smart Lock
Physical fit and failure behaviour come first; convenience features come after.
- Measure the door and existing hardware to establish what will fit.
- Decide whether the exterior appearance and existing keys need to stay unchanged.
- Choose credential types that suit everyone who needs access, including non-phone users.
- Confirm the lockout fallback if batteries fail entirely.
- Check bolt grading and the manufacturer’s security update record.
- Select a connectivity method balancing remote access against battery drain.
Ready to shop? Browse our full list of Smart Locks to compare current options and prices.
